How a TBI Life Care Plan Proves the Cost of a Brain Injury
A traumatic brain injury can change what a person needs for decades. Here, a TBI life care plan does essential work, turning those needs into a documented cost that a New York jury can weigh. Without one, future damages often rest on guesswork. With one, a plaintiff can show what care will cost, year by year, for the rest of his or her life.
Recent verdicts show the stakes. According to the plaintiff’s lawyers, a Bronx jury on February 4, 2026, awarded $36.4 million in Rosario-Silverio v. PPC Commercial, LLC. Those lawyers reported that the award included $10 million for future medical expenses. Notably, the case involved a mild traumatic brain injury along with shoulder and spine injuries. Our post on mild TBI lawsuits in New York explores why a mild diagnosis can still carry lasting harm. Because the result is a jury verdict, it may still face motions or an appeal.
What a TBI Life Care Plan Is and Who Prepares It
At its core, a life care plan is a written projection of the services an injured person will need. Each service carries a cost and a time frame. Usually a life care planner leads the work, gathering records and interviewing the injured person and family members.
First, the planner consults treating physicians and rehabilitation specialists so that every recommendation has a medical basis. Next, an economist takes the projected costs and addresses how they grow over time. This expert may also explain what those costs are worth in present value.
As a result, the plan becomes a bridge between the medical team and the jurors. Doctors describe what the injury requires. Meanwhile, the planner and economist translate those opinions into dollar figures a jury can actually use. Beyond that, a credible plan avoids padding. Recommendations that treating doctors have already made often carry more weight than wish lists created for litigation.
What Goes Into a Life Care Plan
Every plan reflects the specific person, but the categories are familiar. Therapies often come first: physical therapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy and cognitive rehabilitation. Attendant care follows, ranging from a few hours of help each week to supervision around the clock.
In addition, the plan lists medications and their expected duration. It covers equipment such as wheelchairs or mobility aids, along with the cost of replacing them as they wear out. Home modifications, like ramps or accessible bathrooms, round out the picture for many people with serious injuries.
Some plans also include vocational services, transportation to appointments and periodic evaluations by specialists. For a younger person, those line items may stretch across 40 or 50 years. Even small annual costs can add up to large totals over that span. Vocational services matter most when an injury ends a career, an issue that often arises in brain injury lawsuits after construction accidents.
Defendants rarely accept these numbers at face value. Often they hire their own experts to challenge the plan, starting with an independent medical examination in New York. Because of this, each line item needs support in the medical records and in the testimony of the treating team.
How New York Juries Itemize Future Damages
Under CPLR 4111(e), a jury in a personal injury action itemizes each category of future damages. It also states the period of years each award is meant to cover. A life care plan fits that format well, since it already breaks care into categories and time spans. For example, a jury might award one amount for attendant care over 30 years and another for medications over 45 years. That means the verdict can mirror the plan line by line.
Such a structure helps jurors reach a number they can explain. Instead of one large figure, they can award a set amount for future medical care over a stated number of years. Future pain and suffering receives its own separate line on the verdict sheet.
Itemization also matters after trial. Judges reviewing a verdict can see exactly which category the jury funded and for how long. Therefore, a well-supported TBI life care plan can help protect an award from later attack.
How CPLR Article 50-B Pays Future Damages Over $250,000
Even so, a large verdict does not always arrive as a single check. Under CPLR 5041, when future damages exceed $250,000, the court directs payment of up to $250,000 in a lump sum. Any remaining amount goes into an annuity, and those payments increase by 4 percent each year.
This payment structure makes an accurate plan even more important. Since the annuity spreads money across the years of care, the plan’s timeline shapes how the award is paid out. Fortunately, New York appellate courts have sustained large future medical awards backed by thorough proof.
One example comes from the First Department. In 2011, that court decided Angamarca v. New York City Partnership Housing Development Fund. There, it upheld about $16.7 million in future medical expenses for a brain injury requiring care around the clock.
Build Your TBI Life Care Plan With The Law Firm of Andrew M. Stengel, P.C.
The Law Firm of Andrew M. Stengel, P.C. represents people throughout New York living with the long-term effects of brain injuries. Our traumatic brain injury practice works with planners, treating physicians and economists to document future needs. Many of these injuries follow falls at work, which our construction accident practice also handles across New York.
Contact us to discuss your case. Email info@stengellaw.com or schedule at https://calendly.com/stengellaw.

